1
Equipment and Software / Re: Oh no! All grain!?!?
« on: September 12, 2012, 03:01:46 AM »
The big difference between a cooler and a pot is ease of use (in the beginning) and cost. A cooler tun normally will run less than $100 buying everything new where most kettles start at that price point. The cooler has the advantage of being insulated completely making holding temps easy and you really don't have to worry about where you place it (on the ground, stand, table, etc). The downside of a cooler is it is limited in doing complex mashs (need to do decot. or multiple infusions) and has a volume limit (limiting the number of infusion you can do to hit common mash temps either by the volume of water needs to be added or by temp of water that needs to be added).
A pot on the other hand eliminates the downsides of a cooler in being able to be heated, but it is more difficult to maintain a constant mash temp. A burner is nice here to both heat the strike water and keep it off the ground. Then you also have the option of rims herms and dfrims, which I a completely different discussion. I run a df(direct fire) rims and it is nice to have no real worry about missing temps either way, either add heat or add water.
As for pump march pumps are the standard for brewing on the hot side atleast. Most of the chigger pumps say that they are not to be used with boiling liquid. An for chiller, well it depend on batch size. For 5g batches immersion chillers are great and affordable. For 10 and especially larger batches, plate chillers are the better option (remember that the chiller will displace some volume so 10g batch in a 12.5g kettle with 100' 1/2" chiller could get messy). The biggest draw back to plate chillers is their ability to get clogged without taking some extra precautions (hop sacks, filter of some sort aka hop back with hops or rice hulls).
Best advice is use what you like and are comfortable with, also go bigger than what you expect you will need to save cash when you want to brew more later.
A pot on the other hand eliminates the downsides of a cooler in being able to be heated, but it is more difficult to maintain a constant mash temp. A burner is nice here to both heat the strike water and keep it off the ground. Then you also have the option of rims herms and dfrims, which I a completely different discussion. I run a df(direct fire) rims and it is nice to have no real worry about missing temps either way, either add heat or add water.
As for pump march pumps are the standard for brewing on the hot side atleast. Most of the chigger pumps say that they are not to be used with boiling liquid. An for chiller, well it depend on batch size. For 5g batches immersion chillers are great and affordable. For 10 and especially larger batches, plate chillers are the better option (remember that the chiller will displace some volume so 10g batch in a 12.5g kettle with 100' 1/2" chiller could get messy). The biggest draw back to plate chillers is their ability to get clogged without taking some extra precautions (hop sacks, filter of some sort aka hop back with hops or rice hulls).
Best advice is use what you like and are comfortable with, also go bigger than what you expect you will need to save cash when you want to brew more later.

