Clint,
I hear ya, again, I am sorry. I will buy you a beer at NHC if you are going to Philly!
Now, what does disappoint me is that the judges did not bring it to the attention of my staff or me during judging. A good judge should always question an entry if its clearly out of style in a category. Its always worth having the organizer do a check in the system and see what they can determine.
I have seen this where the second bottle was correct (brewer or organizer switched a label or whatever) and I have seen it where it was still wrong and there was not another entry that the brewer could have switched (or even had another entry). Point is that the judge brought it to someones attention vs. just douche'n on it!
Glad to hear your feedback overall was generally good. In larger competitions, it's always a challenge to make sure judges are doing what they "should" be doing!
Cheers brother!
Big Frank
I agree that the judges should have said something. I always do when one of the entries is crearly out of style.
I once had four beers in the NHC finals and two bottles apparently got mixed up. The notes on the braggot were, "this is a very good APA" and on the APA, "way too much honey flavor." That was very disappointing.