I have had the best luck with McCormick's Pumplkin Pie Spice. It has better flavor than anything I have made up on my own.
Be careful with Star Anise. A little goes a loooooong way.
Brewing since 1989 - BJCP National Rank
Conditioning: Burton Ale, Belgian Quad, Old Ale
On tap: Cider, Impy Cherry Stout, Irish Red Ale, Irish Red Lager, Big Irish Red Ale, Rye Dunkel Bock, German Easter Lager, Mexican Lager, Belgian Dubbel Chocolate Stout
Newly Bottled: Dubbel, Belgian Golden Strong, Belgian Easter Ale