Homebrewers Association | AHA Forum

General Category => General Homebrew Discussion => Topic started by: abraxas on August 07, 2010, 06:25:25 PM

Title: Scottish Ale Chloride to Sulfate Ratio
Post by: abraxas on August 07, 2010, 06:25:25 PM
I recently brewed a Scottish 60 and a Wee Heavy.  I adjusted my water to 66:46 ppm Chloride Sulfate thinking that on this style of beer I would want to have a malt emphasis water base.  As I am learning more about water profiles I am learning that this style would actually (probably) be better with a 1:2 ratio more similar to the Edinburgh water profile (45:105).

Edinburgh - Think of misty Scottish evenings and you think of strong Scottish ale - dark ruby highlights, a sweet malty beer with a mellow hop finish. The water is similar to London's but with a bit more bicarbonate and sulfate, making a beer that can embrace a heavier malt body while using less hops to achieve balance.

I can adjust my beers easily enough with a little Gypsum (I have room for some more Calcium) added to the kegs but I am thinking I have been thinking about this all wrong.  A heavily hopped beer (AIPA) should have a malt emphasis to balance the hop bitterness and a malty recipe should have the reverse.  Is this a good very basic rule of thumb? 

I know this is going to vary according to recipe and desired outcome so I guess what I am asking instead is my original thinking that a malt-emphasized style should have a high Cl/SO4 was wrong?  I would like to set up some experiments so I can understand this better I just want to have a little more basic understanding....

Title: Re: Scottish Ale Chloride to Sulfate Ratio
Post by: joeysmokedporter on August 07, 2010, 07:13:33 PM
your original thinking is conventional wisdom and is the same way I would have approached the Scottish.  However, nothing like an experiment to put it to the test.  I'd be interested to hear your results if you do.