I might not need the Chocolate malt. That still may go away. I have to brew this beer soon or this recipe will be completely different than when it was first thrown together. Burning River is a pale ale, and SN Celebration is an IPA. I guess I am going more for the "red" taste other than actual color. If you haven't tried Green Flash Hop Head Read, Oskar Blue's G'Knight Imperial Red IPA, or New Belgium's Red Hoptober, then I suggest you try them. That's the malt flavor I'm trying to achieve. Hop Head Red has a stronger malt taste than the other two. Normally I do not prefer a heavy malt taste in a traditional IPA, but since it's a red IPA, I'm all about it.