We got the judging forms in the mail yesterday. Very quick, as the awards were just this past Saturday.
The sheets were different than BJCP. They had each major category, but then a line with each one with "bad" on one side, and "good" on the other, then the judge would place a tick mark on where they felt the beer scored. Almost a 1-10 scale, but not really. Each category line has a "normal" range.
For our Amber, one judge scored it quite well, one really did not enjoy it, and the third was not so bad, but not great either. The comments from two judges indicated diacetyl. I should have kept one bottle from that batch to taste while reading the judging sheets. Looks like I need to work on my fermenting process.
All in all the judging sheets are brief, but informative. No numerical score. We will enter again.