Hey ktrappe, welcome ! I can't speak specifically to Noblesville's water, but in general the water from Indiana and big chunks of the Midwest is less than desireable (as is) for many styles of beer. I waited a long time to start looking closely at water and therefore some styles came out pretty good , others not so much. IMO, the best approach around here is to use RO (reverse osmosis) water that you can fill at the grocery store from the machine in gallon jugs as a base for all beers. I then add various water salts and sometimes lactic acid to get the right water profile for the right beer.
Martin Brungard (from Carmel) has outstanding software to walk you through 'building your water'. I highly recommend downloading it. It has made my beers consistently better, light to dark, hoppy to malty :
https://sites.google.com/site/brunwater/Good luck !