First one is to just bitter with columbus instead of magnum and finish with your cascade, centennial and mosaic. The dankness will be there, but just in the bitterness and not flavor and aroma.
This is why I moved some columbus to 20. I want some of that strong/harsh columbus flavor. I think it helps give a backbone to the overall flavor. Maybe I'll do both. Unsure if I want to bring the cascade back.
The more I drink it, the more I like it. I may just leave it as is and let those that don't like it drink one of the other four beers. I guess we will see tomorrow during "the big game".
Yeah. They'll drink it. I had four beers on tap at my wedding. A cherry wheat, a very mild, smooth golden ale lightly hopped with Citra and galaxy, an APA finished with only cascade, and an IPA with C hops. The pale ale went first (not surprised), then the IPA (surprised), golden ale and lastly the cherry wheat.
You have to think, people who like IPAs are going to drink several of them, so I wouldn't worry about it too much. The ladies liked the cherry wheat, but they only drink one or two. So, the guys drinking the IPAs didn't touch this until the IPAs were gone. The golden ale appeased a lot of the BMC drinkers. I wouldn't fret too much about it, they'll drink it. Besides, it's your wedding! I was worried about having an IPA altogether and was going to go with two different APAs. Until I said screw it and wanted to drink an IPA at my wedding lol. "Hoppily Ever After"... That was the name lol.
Also another thing that helps non craft beer drinkers at an event like this is to put together a nice beer menu that includes a great description of the beers and ABV.