Call me a luddite, but I liked the original "Flying Y2" better. Except for the yellow border on the lettering.
Of course, what I think looks cool and what pushes beer are 2 different things, but for better or worse I felt like there was an early-30s crowd appeal to the original, not unlike the new Yellowtail wine labels. Trendy and modern but not over the top, almost a thumbing of the nose to old-world snobbery. And a certain amount of cockiness that almost seems to reassure that what's inside the bottle can pull off a label like that.
Would I be out of line to suggest that it suits you? I mean it in the most offensive of all possible ways, of course.