I guess I don't see it they way some of you do.
I think there is a market for kits, if not, then every home-brew store would not be selling them.
The fact that this service has the potential to give back to the brewing community, is a win in my book.
I do understand the concerns posted, but as a whole the home brewing movement is based on innovation, risk, and thinking out of the normal box, and I think this is just an extension of that.
Disclaimer: I have signed to be part of this idea:
1. If helping this succeed is as simple as copying a few of my fav brews, then why not?
2. if selling a kit, helps me buy the grains for my next brew, then why not?
3. it gives new AG brewers another option besides supporting the big box brew stores, and there is nothing wrong with options.
This is just my take of course, and everyone has a valid opinion.
T