good catch. supposed to base + rye = 90-92%
Even at 73% 2row, 18% rye, and 9% carared I think I'm looking at a color of 9. That's not red. If I max the carared to 25% it looks like about 15.5, which is getting there.
Red X is not in the calculator I use but I adjusted dark munich to where Red X is supposed to be. Coupled with 18% rye, I think I can get 20.8srm and OG 1.059. I'm not the best with color, but that seems pretty red to me (maybe even brown).
Adding what goschman said - about 9% carared - to that would be 22.5srm. That's too brown I think?