Hey all, this is more of a general process\flaw detection question, but it's technically an all-grain batch so:
Made what turned out to be a killer beer for my birthday over the summer - just re-brewed a few weeks ago.
It's a bruiser of a IIPA, coming in at 11.5 %ABV (all 2-row except 3.5% rye, 3.5% cara-vienna and 6% cane sugar). Has nearly a pound of high-alpha hops. Largest additions are at flameout and gets double dry-hopped (5-days each). Second dry-hop addition was in the O2-purged keg when I pulled them, cold-crashed it, hit it will gelatin and it was diamond-bright (except for minor residual hop matter) in 48 hrs.
As I was tasting it 24hrs after adding gelatin, life was wonderful: it was full of massive citrus, floral, blackberry, and green tea aromas with a touch of dankness in the bank. Spicy, warming alcohol and just enough malt sweetness to give some semblance of balance. If anything it was better than the first iteration.
Literally on day 3 after fining, the beer now pops with a big, cloying caramel note in the aroma and flavor. Totally different beer.
So, does anything jump out as a culprit? My only guess is oxidation at this point - but this is such a dramatic shift, I really don't know. My original birthday beer was only dry hopped-once due to time constraints and consumed the night of the party so I wasn't able to fine that one or even age it so don't know if the same issue would have arisen.
Any insights as to the cause of this unfortunate turn of events is welcome!
Cheers!
- Ryan