Tired Hands makes some excellent beers of different styles. They aren't yeasty or gritty. I haven't had the milkshake series but it sounds like it was intentionally... um, experimental. Probably not my thing but not necessarily representative of what they do.
Also, Admore, PA is maybe 20 miles north of the Mason Dixon line.
Edit: This is probably why the "Bros" trashed it while giving Heady a 96. Uneducated, sheltered, provincial a-holes (ask me how i really feel...)