I step-mashed this beer at 134* and mashed out around 170*
Where those your only two rests?
I missed my gravity a bit. It read 1.040 after I crashed it to the 70s.
What were you aiming for?
Please let me know what sounds best.
You underpitched quite a bit. Assuming you don't have any other yeast to pitch, you've got a couple different options. If I were you, I'd either keep it where it is or raise the temp a few degrees and then let it finish out from there without attempting to cool it down further once it gets going.
You're not in an ideal situation, but that's probably your best bet at this point.
It is currently around 58* but does not look very active.
See what it looks like in another day if you hold the temp or raise it a bit.