I want to kind of take what you’ve said and parse it so we can hit everything you asked/commented on.
<snip -- edited out text for brevity>
As far as the serving pressure add to the sum total, you are correct. It’s not all added up front, but again, we made some assumptions here:
1.) You are sufficiently purging your kegs. That means liquid purging the ENTIRE keg, including the entirely of the headspace (liquid coming out of the PRV). If you aren’t doing that, you are adding to the DO in the finished beer.
2.) We assumed 2.5 volumes of carbonation. Obviously anything higher increases the DO in the finished beer.
3.) Again, we assume a grade of CO2 that is of a much higher purity than most are probably using.
Ultimately we just wanted to bring to light something that may not have been on people’s radar.
Cool, thanks for the detailed response!
So at least on the cold side, it seems like homebrewers have (more or less) two options to minimize cold side aeration effectively:
1) Complete keg purging+careful closed transfer+spunding+food-grade CO2+cold storage -- slow, but the Cadillac option in terms of minimizing oxygen content at start
2)
Complete keg purging+careful closed transfer+food-grade CO2+cold storage -- faster, some potential for near-term oxidation, but likely minimal if you follow this protocol precisely with high-quality CO2 and careful keg purging.
And adequate purging and good quality CO2 really are the key steps.