Made my third extract batch today and everything seemed to go smoothly - until I took a sample from the wort before pitching my yeast and did an original gravity reading. I'd forgotten to do it on the first two batches - they turned out nicely but I wanted to learn more about my final product. According to my recipe, for an American Pale Ale, my OG should have been around 1.053. It is 1.100. Barley wine territory. Adjusting for 74 degrees up in the kitchen, that's 1.1017. Here's my recipe:
OG 1.053
FG 1.010
IBU 48.47
ABV 5.66 %
SRM 4.86
Specifics
Boil Volume 3 gallons
Batch Size 5 gallons
Boil time: 40 minutes
Fermentables
% Weight Weight (lbs) Grain Gravity Points
42.9 % 3.0 Light Dry Malt Extract 25.2
57.1 % 4.0 Light Malt Extract Syrup 28 (ADDED AT THE 30-min MARK)
7.0 53.2
Hops
% Wt Weight (oz) Hop Form AA% AAU Boil Time Utilization IBU
33.3 % 1.5 Columbus Whole 15 22.5 25 0.104 38.18
16.7 % 0.50 Columbus Whole 15 7.5 10 0.049 7.5
16.7 % 0.50 Columbus Whole 15 7.5 5 0.049 7.5
33.3 % 1.5 Chinook Whole 7 Dry hop 0.0 0.0
Boiled: 2.11.18
Basement floor temp: 61 degrees
I have to say that hydrometers have never struck me as what you'd call precision instruments. But this is probably user error. What did I do wrong? Is this repairable by, say, adding some boiled/cooled water to dilute the wort at this early stage, whether or not the yeast has been pitched? Suggestions, please! And thanks.