It is a little extra clean up, but no big deal.
Our beers are consistently improving. But we feel it is the recipe as much as anything. Plus decades of experience is finally paying off.
Like a friend said…”It’s not the brewery, it’s the Brewmaster.”
I tend to think of it like a 3 legged stool - Ingredients (combined recipe and freshness), Brewing experience (however learned - and I have learned a lot from the participants on this forum), and Process (your system tweaked to work right for your end goal). Those work together to bring about the best results (and for me that means flavorful, crystal clear beer, usually).
I agree! Like you, I have learned from the nice people on this forum. Especially tips on grains, and yeast.
Many years go I reached an opposite conclusion....I decided that recipe is a minor part of the process. A great recipe does you no good if you can't pull it off.
This comes as a surprise, as we have discovered good recipes most often produce good beer. And we have discovered that less is actually more. One grain, one hop. Awesome beer!
So the inverse must also be true, a good brewer can make outstanding beer with a very poor recipe.
I think it kinda depends on the definition of poor recipe. A recipe that was nothing but 10 lb. of crystal won't turn out well no matter the skill of the brewer.
Also, I firmly believe in no artificial limits. Yeah, you can make great beer with one malt and one hop. But you can also make great beer with 5 malts and 7 hops if those are carefully and thoughtfully chosen.
As an example, we just brewed a pale lager, Czech / German style, with 100% Floor Malted Bo-Pils grain. We used 2 hops, Tetnang & Saaz. This has turned out to be one of our best beers, and has rapidly become my favorite.
On the other end, both of my English Imperial Stout and English Barley Wines used a complicated grain and hop recipe. And both of these are quite good.
So I agree with you 100%. But we will continue with cloud free clear wort. It seems to work for us. And as stated, it helps with clean yeast harvesting. This may be the biggest advantage.