I would favor harvested slurry as well, though I have never tried the split starter method you mention. But for a reason. I repitch to quite a few generations, and out of experience share the general view that yeast doesn't really come into its own, adapted to actual brewery conditions and performing at its best, until at least couple of generations in. If you are perpetually keeping your source yeast as a starter, essentially a lab culture, you're never getting ideal fermentation performance out of it.