Putting 2 gaskets on your dip tube probably won't improve or degrade your seal. The idea is that the rubber squishes to conform to the metal surface and fill any deviations from perfect flatness. A gasket will probably seal against another gasket, but won't buy you anything. If you use a thinner seal on the dip tube than the original then your poppet spring will be less compressed and won't seal as tightly as before. Mine have lots of compression, though, and with the addition of pressure from the keg they should seal just fine even with a thinner gasket on the dip tube. Bottom line: it probably doesn't matter either way. The most important thing is that your o-rings are flexible and not cracked.