Can Homebrewers Predict the Future in Beer?

By Dr. Bart Watson, Brewers Association Chief Economist

Homebrewers have long been thought leaders when it comes to beer, so it makes sense that they would have their finger on the pulse of what is new, exciting, and upcoming in beer trends. Heck, they are probably the ones setting some of the trends. But is there a way to see the relationship between homebrewers and emerging trends in the wider beer marketplace?

To answer this question, I set out to analyze the data on entries in the National Homebrew Competition (NHC), the largest beer competition in the world. The competition receives thousands of entries from all 50 states (and DC) over nearly 30 style categories, and those entries presumably reflect the interests (or lack thereof) amongst some of the world’s most committed homebrewers.

To look at the ever-advancing abilities of homebrewers, I stepped back in the competition to 2011, when there just under 7,000 entries (6,906 to be exact). Next, I lined those entries up against market data from the IRI Group, which looks at the sales of different beer styles via scans at grocery stores, convenience stores, and other off-premise retail locations. Although the NHC and IRI categories don’t line up perfectly, using the sub-styles in each NHC category, I was able to line up entry data with the majority of the IRI data—the exceptions being seasonal and variety packs, which cut across styles.

Although the results aren’t perfect, there is some strong evidence that homebrewers (or, at least, NHC participants) are in fact trendsetters. Looking at the style data, the number of entries in 2011 has a positive correlation with that styles growth from 2011-2015. In other words, the more entries a category had, the more likely that style grew in the marketplace over the next four years. This positive correlation still holds even if we remove IPA, which saw tremendous market growth between 2011-2015. So, homebrewers interest do appear to align with future market movements.

Top 6 Styles

NHC Entries 2011 Market Growth, 2011-2015 (%)
Stout 566 56.3%
American Ale 493 -35.0%
IPA 462 96.9%
Fruit Beer/Spice/Herb/Vegetable 429 78.1%
Belgian Strong Ale 404 -31.7%
Belgian and French Ale 394 136.8%

Incidentally, a state’s participation in the NHC is also a good predictor that brewery openings are coming. I also ran the NHC entries by state against the number of brewery openings by state, controlling for population on both variables. The results show a strong relationship between the number of entries by state in 2011 (per million 21+ adults) and the number of breweries that opened between 2011 and December 2015 (again shown below per 21+ adults).

Because Colorado is a bit of an outlier, I decided to run a multiple regression controlling for the distance between Colorado and the state in question (in case the NHC gets more entries closer to Colorado and states closer to Colorado might be predisposed to get more breweries). Controlling for distance actually strengthened the findings.

Homebrewers Predict Future

The relationship between NHC and brewery openings makes a lot of sense – committed homebrewers are likely to support small and independent breweries, as well as potentially open breweries themselves.

State

*NHC Entries/1 mil 21+ adults **Net Brewery Increase/1 mil 21+ adults
*Year used to calculate these results was 2011. **Years used to calculate these results were 2011-2015.
Colorado 25.9 38.7
Wyoming 23.9 23.9
Minnesota 18.2 29.8
New Hampshire 17.3 29.5
Nebraska 16.6 10.6
Oregon 15.5 34.0

So to sum, NHC entries:

  1. Appear to relate to market changes in future years, suggesting homebrewers have a good sense of what the larger market of beer lovers is interested in and what professional brewers will soon be brewing more of, and
  2. Where there are committed homebrewers, there are opportunities for new breweries, possibly started by those homebrewers themselves.
Homebrewers Association
Homebrewers Association

 
Get a Free Trial Issue of Zymurgy®