[purduekenn]

I brewed yesterday and used Ascorbic Acid for the first time. For a 3.5 gallon batch I added 0.35 tsp to the mash and 0.35 tsp with 5 minutes left in the boil. At the 5 minute mark the foam was massive and I turned down the power and stirred the wort to avoid a foam mess. Maybe I should have added the Ascorbic Acid in water before adding it to the boil?

[BrewBama]

I’ve only used AA in the mash. I have been adding 1 tsp to 7.5-7.75 gal strike water (No Sparge) as an antioxidant. However, with my water and processes, I found I was getting low pH. In my last two beers I eliminated the AA from my recipe completely and found my mash at 5.3 and 5.4 at mash temp. I probably won’t be using it again.

One less thing.

[purduekenn]

OK thanks!. I wondered if using Ascorbic Acid would lower the mash pH.

[ynotbrusum]

I don't use it - but I understand the shelf stability enhancement and oxygen scavenging aspects that others tout.  Like any acid, it will effect pH and that must be factored in when using it.  Here is one brewers take on Ascorbic Acid use:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vriDv0XrJj0

Cheers.

[purduekenn]

I don't use it - but I understand the shelf stability enhancement and oxygen scavenging aspects that others tout.  Like any acid, it will effect pH and that must be factored in when using it.  Here is one brewers take on Ascorbic Acid use:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vriDv0XrJj0

Cheers.

Thanks for the comment I agree and Brewers Friend water calculator shows that. I got busy on brew day and forgot to take a mash pH reading
According to Brew Smith and Brewers Friend calculators mash pH should have been between 5.4 - 5.5. But I wished I checked the mash pH!

[jeffy]

I don't use it - but I understand the shelf stability enhancement and oxygen scavenging aspects that others tout.  Like any acid, it will effect pH and that must be factored in when using it.  Here is one brewers take on Ascorbic Acid use:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vriDv0XrJj0

Cheers.

Thanks for the comment I agree and Brewers Friend water calculator shows that. I got busy on brew day and forgot to take a mash pH reading
According to Brew Smith and Brewers Friend calculators mash pH should have been between 5.4 - 5.5. But I wished I checked the mash pH!

I usually add some lactic acid to my strike water for pH adjustment, especially when using mostly pale grains.  Can I substitute ascorbic acid?

[purduekenn]

I don't use it - but I understand the shelf stability enhancement and oxygen scavenging aspects that others tout.  Like any acid, it will effect pH and that must be factored in when using it.  Here is one brewers take on Ascorbic Acid use:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vriDv0XrJj0

Cheers.

Thanks for the Genus brewing video link about Ascorbic Acid. From the video it appears that it doesn't effect mash pH so I would not use it to replace Lactic or Phosphoric acid.

[denny]

I don't use it - but I understand the shelf stability enhancement and oxygen scavenging aspects that others tout.  Like any acid, it will effect pH and that must be factored in when using it.  Here is one brewers take on Ascorbic Acid use:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vriDv0XrJj0

Cheers.

Thanks for the comment I agree and Brewers Friend water calculator shows that. I got busy on brew day and forgot to take a mash pH reading
According to Brew Smith and Brewers Friend calculators mash pH should have been between 5.4 - 5.5. But I wished I checked the mash pH!

I usually add some lactic acid to my strike water for pH adjustment, especially when using mostly pale grains.  Can I substitute ascorbic acid?

I recall discussing this with someone....maybe Martin. The conclusion was that you'd have to use so much it would impact the flavor.

[ynotbrusum]

Yeah, I don’t use it, so I haven’t checked the pH readings when using it, but it should be factored in, even if only using the suggested range of minimal additions.  It may not move the needle much at all.