^I am a proponent of this ideology, the "wrong" hop in good condition usually gets me better results than the true to style hop that isnt in as good of shape. For this reason, I have quit using Saaz altogether, I just had too many instances of saaz being in poor condition.
I've used US goldings in lagers as a single addition for bittering . I boil very lightly, and I found that some earth and floral character still came through. It was a very pleasant beer and did not taste out of place.
Saaz is funny because it's already a mild and low-alpha hop, generally. There were some people (here? another board?) where someone was placing a direct order with a hop farm in the Czech Republic. You had to place an order in advance and I believe they were whole hops. I'm sure they were excellent. For the rest of us... getting good Saaz is tricky. I think I would go to Yakima Valley as a plan B only because I always seem to get excellent hops from them.
I know I mentioned this but there was a Kolsch brewed by a craft brewery in Chicago and I had some of it on draft at a place where you can play bocce indoors. The beer was good enough for me to contact the brewery and ask for the recipe. The brewer answered and told me that the hops were Nugget to bitter and then Santiam later in the boil. Unusual and untraditional? Yes. Great beer? You bet.
I have been going through a pound of US Saaz from Hop Heaven this year. They have been great. I have been using them in CAP and it the best beer I make. Those hops are the secret ingredient.
Really? US Saaz? Huh. I have tried some US Hallertau and Tettnanger and was not impressed. Also, Hop Heaven is a bit of a mystery... does he GROW hops? Does he buy hops in bulk and mix varieties to make new varieties? If you tell me that his US Saaz are that good then I need to get some. I actually need more Edelweiss so I would be ordering that as well.
The hard thing about the Internet is what tastes good to me may not taste good to you. Maybe I don’t know what I am talking about.
I like the flavor I am getting from the Saaz Hop Heaven sells. It certainly reminds me of the flavor I get from some nice commercial beers.
Here is the description from the Ebay site:
“Saaz hops are the classic lager hop. One of the original "Nobel Hops". These are grown in Oregon's Willamette valley and are beautiful. They give the German beer flavor to your beer with herbal and spicy notes. They can give very light lemon when used in larger amounts. They are used in Pilsners, Bocks, Dunkels, Octoberfests, Wheats, Blonds, US Lagers, in fact they work in all lager styles. They are a signature hop for Bohemian Pilsners.”
Regarding who he (Hop Heaven) is: I believe he is a hop broker. He buys hops in bulk and resells. I have had great luck with Hop Heaven’s hops across many varieties.