In your experience, are Scotch Ales normally cloudy? Recently made one, and its murky -pH was ~5.35, golden promise base, skotrat's boil down first runnings procedure. A bit of a google search and it looks like a lot of commercial examples are cloudy also. what say you?
No, they aren't. It's possible the malt may be part of it (inadequate conversion). The first runnings boil shouldn't be it, although it's unnecessary if you can sustain a good rolling boil for 2 hours. Historically the reason for it was the challenge of getting a full rolling boil at scale. Since they were basically doing a simmering boil, they'd boil for longer. To get the maillard reactions and complexity they wanted, they'd boil down some of the first runnings.
The issue is almost definitely going to be a protein issue (protein and polyphenols are typical haze producers, but a scotch ale typically isn't going to be highly hopped so polyphenols from the hops probably aren't it). What were your mash and boil parameters? Some UK malts take a little longer to fully convert. I do a barleywine style mash on my scotch ale (~149F for 90-120 minutes with a mashout of 168F water) and then a 120 minute full rolling boil. Chill haze is obviously a possibility too. Did you try letting it warm to see if it went away? I'm assuming you used Edinburgh yeast? It's normally a very good flocculator and will drop clear without any finings (full disclosure: I do use Whirlfloc in the boil to reduce the break/trub that goes into the fermenter).
Yes, there are some US commercial examples that are cloudy, but I suspect they are inadequate conversion issues. None of the ones I've had from Scotland have been cloudy.