I'm not a huge fan of the regular Tullamore, but their reserve is outstanding.
The Jameson 12 year is outstanding as well.
I've moved away from the non-reserves, unless its Red Breast or Green Spot. But those are pricey bottles at their entry level.
EDIT: Not to crap all over your selections. I would certainly join you for a flight. As long as I could have two ryes and skip the Scotch.