Damn, you've all been busy.
Bourbon favorites are Elmer T. Lee, Eagle Rare, Noah's Mill, and Preston's Double Barrel.
Haven't had Preston's but I'll check it out because your other recommendations are outstanding. I've got two bottles of Noah's in the cabinet. One I bought, and one I got for Christmas.
People keep recommending Blanton's, but I just can't get behind that. Too expensive for what you get. Yeah, it's smooth. But it's boring. I'll drink it if you're pouring, but I won't spend the coin. I'd rather have Four Roses Single Barrel.
Buffalo Trace? Meh. It's OK. I'd put it on par with Makers. Solid, not outstanding. Nothing special to recommend it.
I got everything to make a sazerac! Well it's angastora bitters not peychauds... will have to try one come cocktail hour this afternoon!
Get some Sazerac rye if you can find it. Outstanding stuff.